Red Agate Vs. Carnelian: What’s The Difference?

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. Know more.

We need to learn the characteristics of our crystals if we are to make the most of them in our work. For example, knowing which crystal to use might be confusing when two or more appear alike or have comparable properties, such as red agate vs. carnelian.

Differentiating between red agate and carnelian (often confused as “carnelian red agate”) can be difficult due to their shared color ranging from deep red to vivid orange. However, they can both have a glossy sheen and include a variety of natural colors.

If you have a reddish-orange crystal, you should definitely make a positive identification of it on the site. Since both red agate and carnelian are chalcedonies, they are very similar to one another.

Microcrystalline quartz, of which onyx and agate are examples, composes this family of crystals. Red carnelian, like agate, is a member of the chalcedony group of stones.

Table of Contents

What Is Red Agate?

In the voids of igneous rocks, silica from groundwater deposits creates agate. The luster comes from a mixture of three different types of naturally existing rock and mineral structures: cryptocrystalline silica, chalcedony, and microgranular quartz.

In addition to the apparent orange and yellow banding, the size and weight of a newly discovered rock can help identify it as an agate. It is simple to identify a polished agate compared to an unpolished one.

You likely have an unpolished agate if it is broken and has evidence of a quartz-like mineral in addition to the colors many types of agate have.

Most agate stones are pretty hefty for their size because of their thick structure. Therefore, the rocks that could be agates should be compared to others in the area.

Red Agate: Meaning And Healing Properties

Agate’s beneficial function relieves abdominal and menstrual cramps and safeguards both mother and unborn child. He is the agate stone for warriors, and he guarantees a trouble-free labor and delivery, as well as relief from fever, epilepsy, eye pain, hearing loss, and drunkenness.

The effects on the mind are just as profound as the physical ones. The agate’s calming energy spreads wherever anxiety has taken root.

Many people will hold a piece of red agate in their hands as they focus on their aspirations and visualize achieving them. Utilize red agate if you are a goal-oriented person and want to solidify your objectives.

Read more: What is Fire Agate Used For?

What Is Carnelian?

Among the two types of chalcedony, the browner of the two is called sard, and it is similar in appearance to the orange-red carnelian gemstones. Carnelian and sard are commonly used interchangeably, however, while sard is more on the brown side of the spectrum and carnelian is more on the red side, the two terms are often used interchangeably.

Carnelian is an obscure gemstone that ranges in color depending on the mineral composition of the stone. The rich rust tones of carnelian are mostly due to iron oxide.

Heat treatment of carnelians is a simple way to enhance the stone’s natural hue—carnelian’s color changes when heated because the iron oxidizes. In fact, most natural gemstones can change color just by sitting in the sun for a while.

Carnelian: Meaning And Healing Properties

Carnelian, like other “fire stones,” stimulates the body by releasing stagnant physical energy. Carnelian is a powerful healing crystal that can mend the body, the mind, and the spirit all at once.

Carnelian’s healing powers are like a hug for people with rheumatism or back pain. The bones and ligaments receive healing energy from the warm vibrations, and you go from feeling stiff and chilly to light and limber.

Carnelian encourages you to express yourself creatively by releasing tension in the body and allowing energy to flow more freely. When we give free rein to our imaginations, we gain a renewed sense of vitality and confidence that helps us go forward.

How To Tell The Difference Between Red Agate and Carnelian?

Red agate and carnelian, like other crystals, are produced from elements that grew under pressure deep below the earth’s surface over time. As a result, they are charged with powerful earth energy and should be purified whenever the wearer is exposed to negative vibrations.

Composition

Carnelian and red agate are both types of chalcedony, which explains why their appearance is so comparable to one another. However, its density is slightly lower than that of quartz crystal since these crystals may not include any specific cracks.

Both red agate and carnelian are crystalline forms of silica; they are both members of the chalcedony crystal family. However, since carnelian receives its hue from of the hematite content as well as the iron oxide content in its composition, red agates do not have a prominent color dispersion like that of a carnelian.

Appearance

In terms of transparency, they range from completely clear to nearly: the red agate could have some mossy patterns or stripes. Conversely, carnelian’s transparency ranges from transparent to opaque.

The stone patterns also vary between the two. When compared to carnelian, red agates have a rougher appearance. Banding patterns can be found all over a red agate’s surface.

The red agate’s banding is probably either lighter or darker in tone than the stone itself. Each stone will typically shatter at a conchoidal fissure and lack cleavage. They are dull or waxy in appearance and have a white streak running through these gems.

Hardness

In spite of the fact that both red agate and carnelian are examples of the chalcedony crystals group and possess comparable shades of warm red and orange, these two types of chalcedony are nevertheless quite distinct from one another. Carnelian and red agate are both fairly tough stones to work with. On the Mohs scale, red agate receives a score between 6 and 7, while carnelian receives a score of 7.

Value

Red agates can range in price from as little as $1 to as much as $3000, depending on the stone’s kind, hue, and origin. As a general rule, tumbled agate is more costly than raw agate, and pieces with particularly vivid colors, fine bands, or rarity of origin command a higher price tag.

The fact that carnelians are not very scarce makes them one of the more reasonably priced gem options. Carnelians with more vibrant red and orange hues are more valuable than their brown cousins. There is a direct correlation between the cleanliness of a stone and its market value.